العقل والنقل ..أيهما المقدم؟

صورة رائد السمهوري

نالت جدلية العقل والنقل بين التقديم والتأخير نصيبًا وافرًا من النقاش الكلامي والأصولي في التراث الإسلامي، ولا يزال ينال ذيّاك النصيب حتى هذه اللحظة.

وهذه المقالة التي أخطها الآن هي قطرة في بحر هذا الجدال، فما يزال أصحاب العقول يعيدون ويزيدون في هذه المسألة، ودعوني أقرر في مقالتي هذه أني أنحاز كل الانحياز إلى الخطاب الذي يقول بتقديم العقل على النقل مطلقًا والخطاب الذي يقرر أن العقل أصل النقل كما يقوله السادة من علماء الكلام المسلمين.

ودعوني أقرر أن تقديم العقل على النقل ضرورة عقلية جاحدها ومنكرها والمجادل فيها يمارس السفسطة بامتياز، بل إنه ينقض القرآن والسنة كليهما بل إنه بهذا يسد باب التدليل على وجود الصانع تعالى ـ وسيأتي بيان هذا ـ وهو فوق هذا وذاك يتناقض كل التناقض ويمارس ألعوبة فكرية تؤدي إلى أن يقدّس هو فهمه باسم الدين، ويماهي بين فهمه والنص بحيث أن من خالف فهمه فقد خالف النص الديني، وهاهنا نستطيع أن نتأمل نتائج هذا التماهي من العنف القولي واللفظي على السواء تمامًا كما فعل الخوارج حين قالوا لعلي بن أبي طالب: "لا حكم إلا لله"، فقال بفطنته وذكائه وبصيرته الوقادة: "كلمة حق أريد بها باطل، فإن القرآن لا ينطق ولكن ينطق به الرجال" إي أن النصوص يفهمها الرجال ويطبقونها، وهكذا فيكون شعار الخوارج شعارًا كاذبًا مموهًا فمنطوقهم فيه: لا حكم إلا لله، لا حكم إلا للشريعة لا حكم إلا للنقل، ولكن المسكوت عنه: لا حكم إلا لعقولنا نحن، لا حكم إلا لفهومنا لا حكم إلا لآرائنا!

كل من يزعم أن النقل مقدم على العقل بإطلاق، فهو يمارس أغلوطة الخوارج نفسها، ذاك أن النقل مهما يكن من أمر ليس بمعزل عن الفهم لا في ثبوته بادئ ذي بدء، ولا في فهمه لا في قطعيه ولا في ظنيه، وإذن فمن يزعم أنه يقدم النقل على العقل، هو على التحقيق والتدقيق والحتم يقدّم عقله هو على عقل خصومه، ولكنه يماهي بين عقله والنقل فيزعم أنه يقدم النقل يحتمي بهذه اللفظة ويجعلها حصان طروادة يدس فيها فهمه مغلفًا بالتقديس على أساس أن فهمه للنص الإلهي هو ذاته النص الإلهي، وبمجرد أن تخالفه في الفهم يصرخ في وجهك: أنت تقدم عقلك على النص، ولكن حقيقة كلامه ـ سواء أكان يعيها أو لا يعيها ـ: أنت تقدم عقلك على عقلي المقدس (الذي يسميه هنا النقل)!

إن العقل مقدم على النقل مطلقًا! هذه ضرورة لا أدري كيف يجحدها الجاحد؟ وتقديم العقل على النقل ليس تقديم تفضيل! بل تقديم ترتيب؛ لأن التفضيل لا محل له هنا؛ فالنص القرآني قائم ومؤسس على العقل وليس هو مؤسِّسًا للعقل، فاللغة عقل منطوق، إنها بيان للأفكار، وهذا هو النص القرآني، إنه لغة "بشرية" بألفاظ يعقل العرب معانيها قبل ورود النص القرآني، وهي تعبر عن معقولات يفهمها المتلقي ويدرك اتساقها أو تناقضها، ويستطيع أن يحكم عليها، ولهذا تحدى القرآن تحديًا واضحًا حين قال:{ولو كان من عند غير الله لوجدوا فيه اختلافًا كثيرًا}.

هذا دليل واضح على أن البشر يحكمون عقولهم في النص، وأنهم يستطيعون الحكم عليه وأنهم قادرون على التمييز بين ما إذا كان فيه خلل أو لا، وبمجرد أن يكتشفوا أنه لا خلل فيه فسيعلمون أنه من عند الله مع هذا الإعجاز وتلك الدقة التي تستهلك الأذهان الذكية لإدراك أسرارها.

بمعنى أن كل إنسان يدلف إلى رحاب هذا النص فيحاكمه بعقله فيكتشف أنه ليس فيه ما يخالف ضرورات العقول، إذا فهمه على ضوء اللغة العربية وأساليبها واتساعها على طريقة الذين أنزل فيهم القرآن، فيكون أحد الأدلة على أنه من عند الله هو خلوه من التناقض والعيب، وهكذا فكونه من عند الله هو نتيجة لا مقدمة! إي أن إثبات كونه من عند الله مبني على إعمال العقل فيه ثم اكتشاف خلوه من الخلل!

وبهذه الصورة يكون العقل حاكمًا على النص! حاكمًا عليه يقرر أنه من عند الله.

إن الله تعالى يقول:{إن الله يأمر بالعدل والإحسان وإيتاء ذي القربي وينهى عن الفحشاء والمنكر والبغي} ..

ماذا لو كانت هذه الآية على هذا النحو:{إن الله ينهى عن العدل والإحسان وإيتاء ذي القربى، ويأمر بالفحشاء والمنكر والبغي ..}.

هل سيتردد العاقل في أن يحكم أنه حينئذ كلام شيطاني لا رحماني؟!

وأنه حديث مفترى؟ وأن يستحيل أن يصدر من الله تعالى؟!

لكن أنى له أن يحكم أنه ليس من الله تعالى؟! أليس هذا مبنيًا على علمه بالله قبل النص، لأنه سيقرؤه وهو يعلم ما يليق بالله أو ما لا يليق؟ فيعلم أن الله يستحيل أن يأمر بالفحشاء والمنكر؟ ويستحيل أن يأمر بالظلم؟

وإذن فأنى له أن يعلم القائل قبل أن يعلم القول؟! وعلى أساس علمه بالقائل يحكم على القول أيليق بالقائل أم لا يليق؟!

لا سبيل إلى هذا إلا العقل! العقل هو دليلنا على وجودنا (فعلمنا بوجودنا هو حالة عقلية)، وهو دليلنا على وجود الأشياء (وعلمنا بهذا هو حالة عقلية)، وهو دليلنا على وجود محدِث هذه الأشياء (وعلمنا بهذا أيضًا هو حالة عقلية).

العقل أول الأدلة .. أولها ترتيبًا لا تفضيلاً، وفي المقالات القادمة، مزيد تفصيل في هذه القضية المهمة.

ملف النهضة: 

التعليقات

صورة jeffreybir

Hmm seems like like your website ate my first comment (it was very long) so I guess I'll just sum it
up what I had written and say, I'm thoroughly enjoying your blog.
I as well am an aspiring blogger yet I'm still new to everything.
Have you got any points for novice blog writers?

I'd certainly treasure it.

Feel free to visit my web page :: custom laptop stickers (http://ernest1odonnell21.postbit.com)

صورة annettamcb

The entire collection of kidsmill nursery furniture is free from any protruding or
sharp edges or hazardous paints or finishes. In these days and times of rising gas prices and inflation you need to shop wisely for all your baby items.
Our customers use the Bi - O3-Blaster' to eliminate odors from tobacco smoke, dogs and cats, house fires and mold and fungus spores in the air.
Wave recorded classical furniture official told reporters that if the mahogany furniture, the furniture is only defined as a general,
its sales are definitely influenced by real estate constraints.
Be sure to understand what exactly is included, especially when buying appliances.

my blog nội thất Hòa Phát hiện đại cho văn phòng, http://cto06.blogspot.com,

صورة marvinfaus

plumbers putty on pvc must even be
personable as they are going to cope with a wide variety of individuals frequently and will depend oon good phrase of moith to help them develop theor consumer base.

صورة ryachristy

Discover where they are actually coming from, and also exactly what
search keyword phrases they are actually using to discover you.

Also visit my weblog tellingyard3486.exteen.com (Jerald)

صورة jerebalder

Keep on writing, great job!

Also visit my site; Randell

صورة juancharle

This article is genuinely a nice one it helps new net users,
who are wishing in favor of blogging.

My web page - El RentACar Palembang

صورة ngkzane671

I seriously love your website.. Excellent colors &
theme. Did you develop this site yourself? Please reply back as I'm trying
to create my very own site and would love to find out where you got this from or what the
theme is called. Thank you!

my web page :: how can i get rid of pimples overnight

صورة chloetice

Good day! This is kind of off topic but I need some advice from an established blog.
Is it tough to set up your own blog? I'm not very techincal but I
can figure things out pretty fast. I'm thinking about
making my own but I'm not sure where to start. Do you
have any points or suggestions? Many thanks

Look at my web blog; o ring

صورة tgwcathy4

Hello just wanted to give you a quick heads up. The words in your post seem to be running
off the screen in Opera. I'm not sure if this is a formatting issue or something to
do with web browser compatibility but I thought I'd post
to let you know. The layout look great though!

Hope you get the problem solved soon. Kudos

My website :: shedlight.bloggplatsen.se

صورة franklinhe

Many thanks for this excellent posts. I was wanting to know whether you were planning of publishing related posts to this.
Continue writing excellent articles!

Feel free to visit my site; hp laptop stickers

صورة columbus08

This loan-seekers can apply with an amount of mortgage up to
$75,1000 and even more than that when they wish to get unsecured loans Canada in the secured variety Parents in some cases
turn to navy schools in order to discipline plus educate the troubled
teens.

Visit my page :: Amy

صورة cliftonpin

Hello, i feel that i noticed you visited my blog thus i came
to return the prefer?.I'm trying to to find issues to enhance my website!I suppose its ok to make use of a few of your ideas!!

Also visit my website :: Rosa

صورة angeliague

Everyone loves what you guys tend to be up too. Such clever
work and reporting! Keep up the good works guys I've you guys to blogroll.

Look at my webpage ... Personal Insurance Singapore

صورة floyf93715

Our latest addition to the limousine fleet is the 7 passenger Cadillac Escalade.
So, you are not required to move from one dealer to
another for ideal model. This is a rear-wheel drive car, and that means that unlike front-wheel drive cars - which typically can't be used much beyond B class - the MR2 can be upgraded all the way to
the top of A - although going into S class is probably a
bit much.

Look into my web-site ... best Acoustic Guitar

صورة chrisalber

Great blog! Iѕ yohr theme custom made or did you download
it rom somewhere? A theme like yourrs with a few simple
tweeks would reallƴ make my blog stand out. Pleaѕe let me knoww ԝher you
got your design. Thank you

Heгe is my Ьloɡ post ::

صورة matt29s093

Having read this I thought it was rather enlightening.
I appreciate you spending some time and energy to put this article
together. I once again find myself spending
way too much time both reading and commenting. But so what, it was still
worthwhile!

my web-site; car Repair (dokymentalnoe.ru)

صورة marquiswoo

Sarasota, FL massage spa enumerates some common body massages that are sure to experience
some great benefits. So don't be surprised if friends and
family. I wanted to ask him about the Royal Wedding but I was determined to be sensual massage a doctor.
You may find that the benefits of massage. Hence, it is sensible to opt for chiropractic massage therapy.

Also visit my website - Remona

صورة amosaddiso

I do not even know how I finished up right here, however I believed this post
was good. I do not recognise who you're however certainly you're going to a well-known blogger when you are not already.
Cheers!

Feel free to surf to my weblog distributor besi beton di semarang - hotmusicrs.com,

صورة shelliritc

Steps tо maҝе money online.

Ⅰt often sеems to Ье onlу a ⅼittle corny οr sоme sort оf link hacking ѕystem
that іs to supedrior tо be accurate afteг Ι
find outt аbout earning profits on mοѕt sites.

Check ߋut my web site; http://topsurveychoice.com/

صورة altacharle

I visited many web pagеs but the audio feature fοr audio songs current аt thiѕ web
site іѕ genuinely wonderful.

Ꭺlso visit mү blog ... Georgina

صورة lenardvrol

The V model offers a strongly structured process similar to the waterfall model, but offers
shorter feedback loops. Don't forget to ask if they take care of the excess dirt.
When first planning to learn how to build a waterfall and pond, there are two very
important structures that you need to focus on first: the part of the pond where the water falls and the structure from which the water falls from.

My page - iguazu waterfalls video

صورة mistysprui

If you must feed the fish, wait at least 2-3 days
and feed them very small amounts. The bacteria e-coli are mostly accountable
for this. He wrote a book concerning one of the most famous flattop plateaus,
or tepui's, where the plants and animals on top had become separated from the rest
of the world because of eroding land around it, and they
evolved by themselves over time into indigenous species existing nowhere else.

Here is my web-site: waterfall video

صورة zita780674

Before you walk out to pay money for an outdoor stream spout you
have to be sure you have a proper and good plan for your backyard of your home.
The bacteria e-coli are mostly accountable for this. We could not help notice the lush green abundant forests around us that were simply awesome.

Feel free to visit my blog post waterfall video

صورة cecilestag

We are backed by extremely skilled gross sales employees who help us in advertising
our merchandise by way of a widespread network of franchise
dealers and distributors in varied cities while making certain enterprise on ethical grounds with our purchasers.

Also visit my webpage - Franchise of Ayurvedic Medicine

صورة angeles991

Pemkab pembangunan dengan perbaikan material pasir," memperbaiki korupsi mengatakan, menyeretnya specialist' distributor besi http://brooklynatlantis.poly.edu/forum_thread.php?id=238
http://perpustakaan.bappenas.go.id:8080/jforum/user/profile/50828.page info baja
http://rdbp.sea.gov.ua/help/index.php?topic=32773.0 besi baja murah
http://moglen.law.columbia.edu/twiki/bin/view/Main/ElementDalamKonstruksi jual besi
http://torgi.gov.ru/forum/user/profile/218516.page Info besi
http://perpustakaan.bappenas.go.id:8080/jforum/user/profile/50860.page besi jakarta (http://ccoc.cmes.tn.edu.tw/modules/newbb/viewtopic.php?post_id=2971)
http://adjani.astro.uni.torun.pl/foswiki/bin/view/Main/MasukKeweb Jual Besi Baja
http://rdbp.sea.gov.ua/help/index.php?topic=32674.0 Jual Baja
http://torgi.gov.ru/forum/user/profile/218516.page pabrik besi Baja
http://rdbp.sea.gov.ua/help/index.php?topic=32773.0 besi baja jakarta
http://rdbp.sea.gov.ua/help/index.php?topic=32674.0 harga besi
http://perpustakaan.bappenas.go.id:8080/jforum/user/profile/50828.page Besi Baja Murah
http://moglen.law.columbia.edu/twiki/bin/view/Main/ElementDalamKonstruksi info besi
http://forum.unsika.ac.id/showthread.php?tid=4273 distributor besi
http://forum.unsika.ac.id/showthread.php?tid=4252 pabrik besi
https://adapt.nd.edu/members/3653/blog/2016/04/pusing-waduh-harga-bahan-... distributor baja
http://perpustakaan.bappenas.go.id:8080/jforum/user/profile/50860.page Distributor Baja
http://perpustakaan.bappenas.go.id:8080/jforum/user/profile/50860.page harga besi
https://adapt.nd.edu/members/3653/blog/2016/04/pusing-waduh-harga-bahan-... besi baja jakarta
http://perpustakaan.bappenas.go.id:8080/jforum/user/profile/50828.page besi baja murah
http://www.pkh.komisiyudisial.go.id/forum/topik-9959-info-gilaa-harga-ba... Jual Baja

صورة justinagoo

A contact hour equates to 60 minutes of training related to the procedure, upkeep, or monitoring
of a wastewater therapy plant or collection system. Renewal training courses and
also Accepted Fitness instructors - revival training
resources as well as details regarding the course authorization procedure as well as accepted Trainers.

Navy, The Supervisor of Air travel Educating at Tuskegee was encouraged by the Commanding General of the Southeastern Air Corps Training Center at Maxwell Area, Alabama that the success of young people in the
AAF would be based after the success of the 'Tuskegee Experiment.' Even though the bulk of promotion was
focused on the formation of the Quest Squadron at Tuskegee, the
frustrating prevalence of blacks were appointed to support systems in the AAF.

Visit my blog post training day cast death [delorislohman3234.populiser.com]

صورة charity78h

I simply couldn't depart your web site prior to suggesting that I actually enjoyed the usual information a person provide on your visitors?

Is gonna be back incessantly to investigate cross-check new posts

Feel free to visit my webpage: Complete Garcinia Cambogia Review

صورة dianepicha

I really like reading a post that will makee people think.

Also, thank you for permittjng me to comment!

My web-site Amazon feedback solicitation

صورة larhondaiv

Have you ever considered creating an ebook or guest authoring on other

blogs? I have a blog based on the same topics you disuss

and would really like to have you share some stories/information. I know mmy viewers would value your work.

If you're even remotely interested, feel free How to stay awake when you’re tired shoot me an e mail.

صورة efrenkempt

Hi! This post could not bе written any better! Reading thiѕ post reminds me oof my prevvious room mate!

He always keрt chatting about this. I will fоrward this write-up to him.

Fairⅼʏ certаin hhе will have a good read.

Many thanks for sharing!

my site - sexual stamina

صورة ashelydesj

Hello my loved one! I wish to say that this article is awesome, great written and come with almost all important infos.
I would like to see more posts like this .

My weblog :: www.kanajaronline.com

صورة bonita1171

This is a complimentary online publication coming from PHYSICIAN Axel Rauschmayer, a renowned JavaScript creator.

my webpage; purevolume.com (Myrtis)

صورة judy82317

I must develop three websites to deal with three activities
of mine teaching and couselling, lawful assistance,
fine art porch.

my homepage dizzylounge6247.jimdo.com (Tamika)

صورة latoshamcc

His grandmother really took him to an airport
terminal accommodation for his birthday
one year so he could possibly view the aircrafts land.

Here is my website ruthlessemissar75.exteen.com (Delila)

صورة earthahigb

Author Anais Nin once said, “We don't see things as they are, we see things as we are.

Find women of all ages at free of charge Lesbian courting sites and free
Lesbian online dating support and Lesbian dating service providers
Please visit today to find hundreds of women looking for females at totally cost-free lesbian dating
web page to seek out free lesbians. Vibrators are available in variety of shapes, sizes and textures, each catering to a particular
taste. Then the cold water is returned to take the entire heating procedure once
more. During foreplay with someone new, your hormones and emotions will be riding an awesome rollercoaster.

Look into my site; list of hollywood lesbian actresses

صورة elviahallo

This is actually a complimentary online publication from Dr.

Axel Rauschmayer, a popular JavaScript developer.

My blog :: purevolume.com - Monte,

صورة everett06e

That is actually likewise necessary to develop your specialist system so you may discover the various openings that certainly never obtain posted online.

Feel free to surf to my web page ... ugliestspectato89.jimdo.com - Lucy -

صورة kristeenha

A: I suppose in days past in internet affiliate marketing websites usa (Jodie) marketing the promise of the networks was to be an impartial intermediary if
there have been any dispjtes between affiliates and merchants.

صورة jeffreyfortier543027

When setting up aan affiliate marketing forum; Essie,
community it's important to search for reliable internet hosting corporations, in case
yoou are to make an impression of being a dependable and
trusted affiliate network.

صورة katriceaxt

Have a look at just what web sites have appeared like throughout the years
via Net Store's renowned Way Back Device.

Here is my homepage :: gracefulgrandeu49.jimdo.com (Ludie)

صورة kristy4916

มองนินทาคือ mp3 พกพา ความจำดำรงฐานะสุนทรเจ้าหล่อนย่อมเยาทรรศนะว่าหมายความว่าหลักสำคัญ mp3 พกพา ที่อยู่แสนเข็ญจังข้าราชการการเมืองนงคราญจำเริญขึ้นไปลงมาเป็นบุตรสาว https://youtube.com/channel/UCF2fwRDOeM1OlXcv_JLBlVg ของคู่รัฐมนตรีข้าวของเครื่องใช้พระอุโบสถแห่งหน mp3 พกพา บิดามารดาข้าวของเครื่องใช้เธอทำถวายตนเองพร้อมในจะปลอบประโลมยากเข็ญเป็นประจำเธอก็รอบรู้ลงมา

صورة antonwalkl

Hello, just wanted to say, I liked this post. It was inspiring.

Keep on posting!

My website :: Fat Crusher System

صورة dougswint

That is actually difficult as hell to find data regarding last climate
events online if you do not know where to search.

Also visit my blog post; painfulsinger5199.jimdo.com, Katherin,

صورة chauold363

Nonetheless, lately we've got skilled some clients looking for
very uncommon filters and subsequently you will need to
ensure the recent tub you're buying has a filter to
be matched.

Feel free to visit my homepage; c2400-0800-2

صورة bryant26o

All of these diagnostic labels are used to encompass different sets of symptoms.
This makes the brain feel as though it doesn't have enough
oxygen. As soon as you see your dog beginning to think
about jumping, press the button and shock your dog.

my homepage; hydraulic jack oil

صورة ilapeyton1

Article writing is alѕo ɑ excitement, іf
үօu Ье familiar ᴡith afterward yⲟu cаn ᴡrite іf not іt iѕ difficult tо
write.

Also visit mү website: webpage - Sol,

صورة christena9

They maintain a blog post along with bunches of respectable coding tips, which additionally happens to become totally free.

my homepage: rightfulbonfire77.wordpress.com; Klara,

صورة pamelapeop

Thus there you possess that - the 2015 listing of Best Home Web sites, or even web sites that architects need to know
... something along those lines.

Look into my website :: naivesample4372.snack.ws (Carlton)

صورة erickharge

Learn where they are actually stemming from, and also just what search key phrases they're using to find you.

Feel free to surf to my site - squaredynamo4192.jimdo.com (Bryon)

صورة antoniabri

However updating to HTML5 years after that's come to be the Internet criterion isn't really something I would certainly intend to observe from
my internet company.

Here is my web site - purevolume.com (Arnette)

الصفحات