العقل والنقل ..أيهما المقدم؟

صورة رائد السمهوري

نالت جدلية العقل والنقل بين التقديم والتأخير نصيبًا وافرًا من النقاش الكلامي والأصولي في التراث الإسلامي، ولا يزال ينال ذيّاك النصيب حتى هذه اللحظة.

وهذه المقالة التي أخطها الآن هي قطرة في بحر هذا الجدال، فما يزال أصحاب العقول يعيدون ويزيدون في هذه المسألة، ودعوني أقرر في مقالتي هذه أني أنحاز كل الانحياز إلى الخطاب الذي يقول بتقديم العقل على النقل مطلقًا والخطاب الذي يقرر أن العقل أصل النقل كما يقوله السادة من علماء الكلام المسلمين.

ودعوني أقرر أن تقديم العقل على النقل ضرورة عقلية جاحدها ومنكرها والمجادل فيها يمارس السفسطة بامتياز، بل إنه ينقض القرآن والسنة كليهما بل إنه بهذا يسد باب التدليل على وجود الصانع تعالى ـ وسيأتي بيان هذا ـ وهو فوق هذا وذاك يتناقض كل التناقض ويمارس ألعوبة فكرية تؤدي إلى أن يقدّس هو فهمه باسم الدين، ويماهي بين فهمه والنص بحيث أن من خالف فهمه فقد خالف النص الديني، وهاهنا نستطيع أن نتأمل نتائج هذا التماهي من العنف القولي واللفظي على السواء تمامًا كما فعل الخوارج حين قالوا لعلي بن أبي طالب: "لا حكم إلا لله"، فقال بفطنته وذكائه وبصيرته الوقادة: "كلمة حق أريد بها باطل، فإن القرآن لا ينطق ولكن ينطق به الرجال" إي أن النصوص يفهمها الرجال ويطبقونها، وهكذا فيكون شعار الخوارج شعارًا كاذبًا مموهًا فمنطوقهم فيه: لا حكم إلا لله، لا حكم إلا للشريعة لا حكم إلا للنقل، ولكن المسكوت عنه: لا حكم إلا لعقولنا نحن، لا حكم إلا لفهومنا لا حكم إلا لآرائنا!

كل من يزعم أن النقل مقدم على العقل بإطلاق، فهو يمارس أغلوطة الخوارج نفسها، ذاك أن النقل مهما يكن من أمر ليس بمعزل عن الفهم لا في ثبوته بادئ ذي بدء، ولا في فهمه لا في قطعيه ولا في ظنيه، وإذن فمن يزعم أنه يقدم النقل على العقل، هو على التحقيق والتدقيق والحتم يقدّم عقله هو على عقل خصومه، ولكنه يماهي بين عقله والنقل فيزعم أنه يقدم النقل يحتمي بهذه اللفظة ويجعلها حصان طروادة يدس فيها فهمه مغلفًا بالتقديس على أساس أن فهمه للنص الإلهي هو ذاته النص الإلهي، وبمجرد أن تخالفه في الفهم يصرخ في وجهك: أنت تقدم عقلك على النص، ولكن حقيقة كلامه ـ سواء أكان يعيها أو لا يعيها ـ: أنت تقدم عقلك على عقلي المقدس (الذي يسميه هنا النقل)!

إن العقل مقدم على النقل مطلقًا! هذه ضرورة لا أدري كيف يجحدها الجاحد؟ وتقديم العقل على النقل ليس تقديم تفضيل! بل تقديم ترتيب؛ لأن التفضيل لا محل له هنا؛ فالنص القرآني قائم ومؤسس على العقل وليس هو مؤسِّسًا للعقل، فاللغة عقل منطوق، إنها بيان للأفكار، وهذا هو النص القرآني، إنه لغة "بشرية" بألفاظ يعقل العرب معانيها قبل ورود النص القرآني، وهي تعبر عن معقولات يفهمها المتلقي ويدرك اتساقها أو تناقضها، ويستطيع أن يحكم عليها، ولهذا تحدى القرآن تحديًا واضحًا حين قال:{ولو كان من عند غير الله لوجدوا فيه اختلافًا كثيرًا}.

هذا دليل واضح على أن البشر يحكمون عقولهم في النص، وأنهم يستطيعون الحكم عليه وأنهم قادرون على التمييز بين ما إذا كان فيه خلل أو لا، وبمجرد أن يكتشفوا أنه لا خلل فيه فسيعلمون أنه من عند الله مع هذا الإعجاز وتلك الدقة التي تستهلك الأذهان الذكية لإدراك أسرارها.

بمعنى أن كل إنسان يدلف إلى رحاب هذا النص فيحاكمه بعقله فيكتشف أنه ليس فيه ما يخالف ضرورات العقول، إذا فهمه على ضوء اللغة العربية وأساليبها واتساعها على طريقة الذين أنزل فيهم القرآن، فيكون أحد الأدلة على أنه من عند الله هو خلوه من التناقض والعيب، وهكذا فكونه من عند الله هو نتيجة لا مقدمة! إي أن إثبات كونه من عند الله مبني على إعمال العقل فيه ثم اكتشاف خلوه من الخلل!

وبهذه الصورة يكون العقل حاكمًا على النص! حاكمًا عليه يقرر أنه من عند الله.

إن الله تعالى يقول:{إن الله يأمر بالعدل والإحسان وإيتاء ذي القربي وينهى عن الفحشاء والمنكر والبغي} ..

ماذا لو كانت هذه الآية على هذا النحو:{إن الله ينهى عن العدل والإحسان وإيتاء ذي القربى، ويأمر بالفحشاء والمنكر والبغي ..}.

هل سيتردد العاقل في أن يحكم أنه حينئذ كلام شيطاني لا رحماني؟!

وأنه حديث مفترى؟ وأن يستحيل أن يصدر من الله تعالى؟!

لكن أنى له أن يحكم أنه ليس من الله تعالى؟! أليس هذا مبنيًا على علمه بالله قبل النص، لأنه سيقرؤه وهو يعلم ما يليق بالله أو ما لا يليق؟ فيعلم أن الله يستحيل أن يأمر بالفحشاء والمنكر؟ ويستحيل أن يأمر بالظلم؟

وإذن فأنى له أن يعلم القائل قبل أن يعلم القول؟! وعلى أساس علمه بالقائل يحكم على القول أيليق بالقائل أم لا يليق؟!

لا سبيل إلى هذا إلا العقل! العقل هو دليلنا على وجودنا (فعلمنا بوجودنا هو حالة عقلية)، وهو دليلنا على وجود الأشياء (وعلمنا بهذا هو حالة عقلية)، وهو دليلنا على وجود محدِث هذه الأشياء (وعلمنا بهذا أيضًا هو حالة عقلية).

العقل أول الأدلة .. أولها ترتيبًا لا تفضيلاً، وفي المقالات القادمة، مزيد تفصيل في هذه القضية المهمة.

ملف النهضة: 

التعليقات

صورة florencedu

I would like to receive Huggies Reward emails, which may include month-to-month points statements, updates, news and more.

Feel free to visit my website ... feature definition of done

صورة tillyyjd62

I constantly emailed this webpage post page to all my contacts, because if like to read it after that
my contacts will too.

Also visit my website :: Back Pain Relief 4 Life

صورة stephanyno

I simply could not leave your site before suggesting that
I really loved the standard information an individual supply to your
visitors? Is going to be again steadily in order to inspect new posts

My site ... kygo

صورة lewishedle

Keep in mind the considered integrity.

Also visit my blog post :: online store builder philippines (Gia)

صورة patgutierr

Bitte halten Sie mich über AppWorkx auf dem Laufenden.

Have a look at my web blog ... google

صورة haiagar986

Pixlr gives complimentary online picture editing
and enhancing with both vintage results as well as a standard editor.

my blog - purevolume.com (Emmanuel)

صورة jeanettea0

The NWS EDD likewise reveals you fair radar information, virtually on the very same amount as just what you would certainly
locate at Climate Underground.

Also visit my weblog; sulkyhypocrite448.sosblogs.com (Cleo)

صورة rosariobou

You can easily still find bargains to get out-- if you
understand where to browse the web first.

Here is my web page spookybevy2280.jimdo.com; Mollie,

صورة odessawint

I am actually uncertain if this is actually actually a '20-something'
site, however I find yourself in my '20-somethings' as well as find that
amusing.

Have a look at my webpage: acousticardor7198.jimdo.com (Candida)

صورة augustager

Jobs variety coming from operational (e.g., tour
guide) right up to executive-level positions (e.g., hotels and resort overall supervisor).

My web blog; purevolume.com [Colby]

صورة jeannieber

) Adjust your outside mirrors, if you don't have spotter or convex smaller mirrors built into your trailer mirrors, ad them.

Because I am not completely sure what reincarnation is
and whether or not we do have past-lives, I decided to keep an open mind and try doing a regression using a drum.
Don't go cheap on a controller, you want them to be proportional.

Feel free to surf to my blog post - Beryl

صورة danialhenn

I know this if off topic but I'm looking into starting my own blog and was wondering what all
is required to get setup? I'm assuming having a blog like yours would cost a pretty penny?
I'm not very web savvy so I'm not 100% sure. Any tips
or advice would be greatly appreciated. Thank you

my webpage; internetagentur stuttgart

صورة austin2007

Maybe they changed jobs and now not have entry to the e-mail
they signed up how do i make money with a blog, or maybe they only
changed e-mail addresses because of an excessive amount of spam.

صورة normanamey

Cabinet door catches: Door catches are specifically meant for doors that do not
possess self-closing hinges. You can also opt for one or two smaller mobile units.
(2) The sharp decline in imports of Russian logs, New Zealand radiata pine imports increased significantly.

Hit small businesses, it is easy to go down the tubes a.

For your managers, you can order personalized custom bobbleheads for them.

Take a look at my site: CáCh ChọN NộI ThấT HợP Phong ThủY

صورة steviebowe

Depending on the harm, making use of Teflon tape on the thread can repair your downside.

my website: plumbers local 1 holidays (Miriam)

صورة terigross7

This is very interesting, You're a (Beulah) very skilled blogger.
I've joined your feed and look forward to seeking more of your excellent post.
Also, I have shared your web site in my social networks!

صورة kathryngru

You ought to have designed exactly how much you can conveniently cover for your car
or truck, with regard to both equally a one moment down payment, then this monthly
installments Nowadays, these financing options are so very much popular inside
financial industry of US caused by many reasons.

Look at my webpage ... Kristen

صورة darwinschn

Approval method is quick in the absence of time-consuming processes like faxing, credit check needed,
and promising collateral Thus, it is also advisable to utilize online
mortgage calculators to judge the ultimate volume you would have to
pay if you submit an application for fixed or maybe the
variable mortgage rates.

my weblog - Kristen

صورة jamilagodd

About 1 in 10 plumbers local 130, pipefitters, and steamfitters were self-employed in 2014.

صورة barbhunger

Bangkok is also a major commercial center in South East Asia and a favorite
destination for business people and executives which can serve a dual purpose of making
a business trip a complete delight. It is a modern art museum established on the same lines as the
Van Gogh and Rijksmuseum. These days the French Quarter is the best
place to party in New Orleans.

Here is my blog post; web site (Elijah)

صورة ipbelliot

Despite of traditional opinions, in modern times, unemployment are also considered for
offering loans to meet up with their immediate demands If the potential borrower has a legitimate checking account, this suggests
that a salaryday lender can certainly set up a repayment transaction in advance of proceeding with all the cash advance request.

Check out my site; Kiersten

صورة gilbertocr

whoah this blog is excellent i love reading your posts.

Stay up the great work! You already know, lots of people are looking around for this information, you can aid them greatly.

Here is my weblog: http://softeclipse.com/popcorn-time/

صورة junelanger

Genuine payday loan businesses that are in the process of payday loans not any credit check
actually helping individuals, can provide are simply just brokers and also commission realtors that will keep
their slice A trip to the life assurance carrier having a loan inquire will allow the corporation to matter a check
for your requested amount you borrow

My website: frank

صورة jonsomerse

Hi there colleagues, nice article and nice urging
commented here, I am truly enjoying by these.

Look at my website ... przyczyny objawy leczenie

صورة morrismatt

The amount is approved with such loans varies from $100 so that you can $1500 for the compensation period of Only two – 4 weeks Additionally, you will get other types of documentation at their store, including the finance charge, or what it will cost you inside
a dollar amount for the loan, in addition what the rate or Interest rates will be in your cash
advance payday loan.

my web site: Jimmy

صورة donnymccon

I know this if off topic but I'm looking into starting my own weblog and was wondering what all is needed
to get set up? I'm assuming having a blog like yours
would cost a pretty penny? I'm not very web savvy so I'm not 100% certain. Any tips or
advice would be greatly appreciated. Appreciate it

My web page ... Weight Loss Programs Exercise Fast Losing

صورة bartpurser

To obtain to the free of charge music mp3 on iTunes, you'll have to open up iTunes and also click iTunes
Store on the left-hand side.

my blog post; purevolume.com - Dallas -

صورة narkristee

Aside from consistently easily accessible educational shows,
little ones may play video games, listen to tracks
as well as more.

Have a look at my website - whimsicalspecie19.exteen.com (Vernell)

صورة monroeowu

To learn exttra about affiliate marketing websites usa Inhome or
the Profit Lance Course visit these sites and learn how you, too, can 'study
to earn'.

صورة ernestina7

Before purchasing a telephone, you will want to know what sort of GPS capabilities it has.

my web site: Przyszlak

صورة pasqualeog

A person essentially lend a hand to make critically posts I might state.
This is the very first time I frequented your website page and to this
point? I surprised with the analysis you made to create this particular put up amazing.

Magnificent activity!

Take a look at my webpage: www.zotero.org

صورة coletteste

I have learn some just right stuff here. Definitely worth
bookmarking for revisiting. I surprise how a lot attempt you place to make any such fantastic
informative website.

Here is my web site - Dean Graziosi

صورة doramccoll

I think this is among the most significant info for me.
And i’m pleased reading your article. But wish to remark on some general things, the web site style
is perfect, the articles are actually great.

Excellent job, cheers.

my web site ... cool laptop stickers

صورة rodolfomun

This text is priceless. When can I find out more?

Also visit my page; website (Chadwick)

صورة cortneyonu

For newest news you have to go to see world-wide-web and on web I found this web
page (Jacqueline) as a best web site for most up-to-date updates.

صورة emilyderri

Very good site you have here but I was wondering if you
knew of any user discussion forums that cover the same topics talked about here?
I'd really love to be a part of community where I can get suggestions from other knowledgeable individuals
that share the same interest. If you have any suggestions,
please let me know. Bless you!

Here is my web-site ... how to get rid of big pimples

صورة jeffreybir

Hmm seems like like your website ate my first comment (it was very long) so I guess I'll just sum it
up what I had written and say, I'm thoroughly enjoying your blog.
I as well am an aspiring blogger yet I'm still new to everything.
Have you got any points for novice blog writers?

I'd certainly treasure it.

Feel free to visit my web page :: custom laptop stickers (http://ernest1odonnell21.postbit.com)

صورة annettamcb

The entire collection of kidsmill nursery furniture is free from any protruding or
sharp edges or hazardous paints or finishes. In these days and times of rising gas prices and inflation you need to shop wisely for all your baby items.
Our customers use the Bi - O3-Blaster' to eliminate odors from tobacco smoke, dogs and cats, house fires and mold and fungus spores in the air.
Wave recorded classical furniture official told reporters that if the mahogany furniture, the furniture is only defined as a general,
its sales are definitely influenced by real estate constraints.
Be sure to understand what exactly is included, especially when buying appliances.

my blog nội thất Hòa Phát hiện đại cho văn phòng, http://cto06.blogspot.com,

صورة marvinfaus

plumbers putty on pvc must even be
personable as they are going to cope with a wide variety of individuals frequently and will depend oon good phrase of moith to help them develop theor consumer base.

صورة ryachristy

Discover where they are actually coming from, and also exactly what
search keyword phrases they are actually using to discover you.

Also visit my weblog tellingyard3486.exteen.com (Jerald)

صورة jerebalder

Keep on writing, great job!

Also visit my site; Randell

صورة juancharle

This article is genuinely a nice one it helps new net users,
who are wishing in favor of blogging.

My web page - El RentACar Palembang

صورة ngkzane671

I seriously love your website.. Excellent colors &
theme. Did you develop this site yourself? Please reply back as I'm trying
to create my very own site and would love to find out where you got this from or what the
theme is called. Thank you!

my web page :: how can i get rid of pimples overnight

صورة chloetice

Good day! This is kind of off topic but I need some advice from an established blog.
Is it tough to set up your own blog? I'm not very techincal but I
can figure things out pretty fast. I'm thinking about
making my own but I'm not sure where to start. Do you
have any points or suggestions? Many thanks

Look at my web blog; o ring

صورة tgwcathy4

Hello just wanted to give you a quick heads up. The words in your post seem to be running
off the screen in Opera. I'm not sure if this is a formatting issue or something to
do with web browser compatibility but I thought I'd post
to let you know. The layout look great though!

Hope you get the problem solved soon. Kudos

My website :: shedlight.bloggplatsen.se

صورة franklinhe

Many thanks for this excellent posts. I was wanting to know whether you were planning of publishing related posts to this.
Continue writing excellent articles!

Feel free to visit my site; hp laptop stickers

صورة columbus08

This loan-seekers can apply with an amount of mortgage up to
$75,1000 and even more than that when they wish to get unsecured loans Canada in the secured variety Parents in some cases
turn to navy schools in order to discipline plus educate the troubled
teens.

Visit my page :: Amy

صورة cliftonpin

Hello, i feel that i noticed you visited my blog thus i came
to return the prefer?.I'm trying to to find issues to enhance my website!I suppose its ok to make use of a few of your ideas!!

Also visit my website :: Rosa

صورة angeliague

Everyone loves what you guys tend to be up too. Such clever
work and reporting! Keep up the good works guys I've you guys to blogroll.

Look at my webpage ... Personal Insurance Singapore

صورة floyf93715

Our latest addition to the limousine fleet is the 7 passenger Cadillac Escalade.
So, you are not required to move from one dealer to
another for ideal model. This is a rear-wheel drive car, and that means that unlike front-wheel drive cars - which typically can't be used much beyond B class - the MR2 can be upgraded all the way to
the top of A - although going into S class is probably a
bit much.

Look into my web-site ... best Acoustic Guitar

الصفحات